Federal prosecutors allege Natalie Greene and Anamaria Moe fabricated a politically motivated assault at a South Jersey nature preserve in 2025.
CAMDEN, NJ — A former staff member for U.S. Rep. Jeff Van Drew and another New Jersey woman have been indicted on federal charges accusing them of staging a violent, politically motivated attack and falsely reporting it to police and federal investigators.
Natalie Greene, 27, of Ocean City, and Anamaria Moe, 25, of Atlantic City, were named in a federal indictment unsealed this week in U.S. District Court in New Jersey. Greene is charged with conspiracy to convey false statements and hoaxes, conveying false statements and hoaxes, and making false statements to federal law enforcement. Moe is charged with conspiracy and conveying false statements and hoaxes. Prosecutors said the charges are allegations and both women are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
The indictment centers on an incident at the Egg Harbor Township Nature Reserve on July 23, 2025. Prosecutors allege Greene had arranged earlier that day to undergo a scarification procedure at a body-modification studio in Pennsylvania, where an artist made cuts on her face, neck, upper chest and shoulder. Court records say Greene had communicated with the artist for weeks about the procedure and paid $500 for it.
After leaving Pennsylvania, Greene drove to New Jersey and picked up Moe, according to the indictment. Prosecutors allege that before the women went to the nature reserve, someone involved in the alleged conspiracy wrote an anti-Trump insult on Greene’s stomach and a message accusing the federal official who employed her of racism on her back. News organizations have identified Greene as a former member of Van Drew’s staff. The indictment itself refers to her employer as “Federal Official 1.”
At about 10:36 p.m., Moe called 911 and reported that three unknown men had attacked the women while they were walking on a trail, according to court records. Prosecutors say Moe told the dispatcher the men had discussed politics, referred to Greene’s government employment and threatened the women with a gun. Police responding to the preserve later found Greene in a wooded area with her hands and feet bound with black zip ties and with injuries from the earlier scarification procedure, the indictment alleges.
Greene allegedly gave officers a similar account after she was found. Prosecutors say she told investigators that three unknown men had approached her, restrained her and threatened to kill her if she made noise. She also allegedly claimed that one of the men had pressed an object against her that she believed was a gun and that the attackers had cut and written on her body. Greene was taken to a hospital for treatment after officers located her.
Federal investigators later developed evidence they say contradicted the account. The indictment states that zip ties found in Greene’s Maserati that night were similar to those used to bind her. It also alleges that an internet search for “zip ties near me” had been made on Moe’s cellphone two days before the reported attack. Investigators also traced Greene’s communications with the Pennsylvania scarification artist and her trip to the studio, according to court records.
Prosecutors further allege that Greene repeated the account during a July 25, 2025, interview attended by an FBI agent and other investigators. She allegedly told them that the three men grabbed her, tied her wrists and ankles, hurt her and threatened to shoot her. The indictment says Greene deleted online messages with the scarification artist after that interview. Federal prosecutors contend those statements were part of an effort to reinforce the alleged hoax.
Greene had previously been charged by federal complaint in connection with the case. The new indictment formally brings the charges before a grand jury and also names Moe as a defendant. Moe made an initial appearance Thursday before U.S. Magistrate Judge Sharon A. King in Camden federal court, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of New Jersey. Greene’s attorney is listed by prosecutors as Louis M. Barbone. Moe is represented by Assistant Federal Public Defender Maggie Moy.
Each charged count carries a maximum penalty of five years in prison, a $250,000 fine and up to three years of supervised release if a defendant is convicted, prosecutors said. The investigation involved the FBI, Atlantic County Prosecutor’s Office, Egg Harbor Township Police Department, New Jersey State Police and U.S. Capitol Police. The case is being prosecuted by federal attorneys in New Jersey and the Justice Department’s National Security Division.
The indictment was filed Nov. 18 and announced by federal prosecutors Nov. 20. No trial date or final disposition of the charges was announced in the material reviewed. Van Drew, a Republican who represented New Jersey’s 2nd Congressional District during the alleged incident, lost his reelection bid earlier this month and remains in office until the end of his current term.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.