Florida Executes Thomas Overton For 1991 Murder of Couple and Unborn Baby

The 71-year-old inmate became Florida’s 20th execution of 2026, surpassing the state’s previous modern-era annual record.

RAIFORD, FL — Florida executed Thomas Mitchell Overton on Nov. 19 for the 1991 murders of Michael and Susan “Missy” MacIvor in the Florida Keys, carrying out the state’s 20th execution of the year and setting a new modern-era annual record.

Overton, 71, was pronounced dead at 6:19 p.m. at Florida State Prison in Raiford, according to the Florida Department of Corrections. His execution came hours after the U.S. Supreme Court denied his application for a stay and his petition asking the justices to review his case. Florida had carried out 19 executions in 2025, then a modern-era state record. Overton’s execution moved the 2026 total past that mark, with additional executions already scheduled for December.

Overton was convicted in 1999 of two counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of Michael MacIvor, 30, and Susan MacIvor, 29. Susan MacIvor was eight months pregnant when the couple was killed at their Tavernier home in August 1991. Overton also was convicted of killing an unborn child, burglary and sexual battery. He received death sentences for the murders, life sentences for the burglary and sexual battery convictions, and a 15-year sentence in the death of the unborn child.

The MacIvors were found dead in their home on Aug. 22, 1991, after they had attended a childbirth class the previous evening, according to court records. Both had been strangled. Investigators also determined that Susan MacIvor had been sexually assaulted. A medical examiner concluded that the couple’s unborn son survived for a period after his mother died. The killings shocked the Upper Keys community, where Susan MacIvor was preparing to begin the school year as a teacher at Key Largo School.

The case remained unsolved for years after investigators collected biological evidence from the home but initially could not match it to a suspect. The investigation changed after Overton, who had worked at a gas station near the MacIvors’ residence, was arrested in an unrelated burglary case in 1996. Authorities obtained a DNA sample from him and later said testing matched him to evidence recovered from bedding inside the MacIvors’ home. Additional DNA testing was used during the prosecution.

At his 1999 trial in Monroe County, jurors found Overton guilty on all charges. Court records show prosecutors also presented testimony from a man who had been jailed with Overton and said Overton discussed the crimes. Defense attorneys challenged the prosecution’s evidence and maintained that DNA evidence had been planted. The Florida Supreme Court later affirmed Overton’s convictions and death sentences, and his case continued through years of state and federal post-conviction litigation.

Gov. Ron DeSantis signed Overton’s death warrant on Oct. 21, scheduling the execution for Nov. 19. In the weeks before the execution, Overton pursued another round of litigation in state court. On Nov. 13, the Florida Supreme Court affirmed a circuit court’s denial of his latest post-conviction motion, denied a separate request for habeas relief and declined to stop the execution. The state court said it rejected the claims Overton had raised and ordered its mandate to issue immediately.

Overton then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to intervene. His application for a stay was filed Nov. 14, and Florida filed a response three days later. On Nov. 19, the Supreme Court denied both the stay request and Overton’s petition for a writ of certiorari. With no court order blocking the sentence, the execution proceeded that evening at Florida State Prison.

In his final statement, Overton continued to deny responsibility for the MacIvors’ deaths. “I never killed anyone,” he said, according to an Associated Press account of the execution. He also specifically denied killing the MacIvors. The state began the lethal injection after his statement, and the Department of Corrections later announced that his sentence had been carried out at 6:19 p.m.

The execution marked a significant increase in Florida’s use of capital punishment. The state carried out 19 executions in 2025 and surpassed that total with Overton’s death. The 20 executions in 2026 are the most Florida has conducted in a single year since the U.S. Supreme Court allowed capital punishment to resume in 1976. DeSantis has defended the use of the death penalty as a way to carry out sentences imposed in long-running murder cases and has questioned why some cases remain in appeals for decades.

Florida’s execution schedule is not finished for the year. Death warrants have been signed for additional executions in December, meaning the state’s 2026 total could rise further if those sentences are carried out as scheduled. Overton’s execution closed the final court proceedings tied to his death sentence more than 35 years after Michael and Susan MacIvor were killed in their Tavernier home.

Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.