Prosecutors say cellphone records, surveillance evidence and a renewed cold-case investigation helped link four men to Jim Johnson Jr.’s death.
ORLANDO, FL — Four men have been arrested and charged in the kidnapping and killing of Jim Johnson Jr., nearly 13 years after he disappeared from an Orlando barbershop and was later found dead in a wooded area of Daytona Beach, Florida authorities announced.
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier and Orlando Police Chief Eric Smith announced the arrests Nov. 19, saying investigators had revisited evidence from the long-unsolved 2013 case and reconstructed the movements and communications of people they believe were involved. Authorities identified the defendants as Carlton Leon Williams, 50, of Orlando; Derrick Lineil Dean, 47, of Orlando; Sean Quentin Daniel Cosby Davis, 35, of Orlando; and Nathaniel Webster, 42, of Altamonte Springs. The charges are allegations, and the defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Johnson, who was 39, disappeared on Dec. 6, 2013, after being seen at Goolie’s Barbershop on South Orange Blossom Trail in Orlando. Authorities said witnesses reported that Johnson disappeared from the rear of the business at about 9:15 a.m. Investigators later found what they described as a significant bloodstain near the place where Johnson’s vehicle had been parked.
Investigators have linked the abduction to a home invasion robbery that occurred the same morning. Prosecutors allege armed participants entered a residence, shot another person in the leg and took cash and valuables from a concealed floor safe. Authorities contend the kidnapping and robbery were part of a coordinated criminal operation involving the four defendants. The surviving victim sought medical treatment, according to officials.
Johnson’s white Cadillac was found several days after he disappeared at an apartment complex in the Orlando area. On Dec. 11, 2013, a passerby found Johnson’s body in a wooded area in Daytona Beach. The Volusia County Medical Examiner determined that his death was a homicide. Contemporary reports said few details about the circumstances of his death were publicly available at the time.
Authorities said the renewed investigation relied on extensive cellphone records, historical cell-site information, surveillance video and other evidence. Investigators used those records to examine communications and movements before, during and after Johnson’s disappearance. Uthmeier said the cellphone evidence helped detectives determine who was communicating and where people connected to the investigation were moving, including activity associated with the Daytona Beach area where Johnson was found.
Each defendant faces charges that include first-degree felony murder, kidnapping, armed kidnapping, armed burglary of a dwelling with assault or battery, armed robbery with a firearm, aggravated battery with a firearm, unlawful use of a two-way communication device and racketeering. The cases also include two counts of grand theft of an automobile, according to the attorney general’s office. Prosecutors allege the underlying offenses were connected as part of a criminal enterprise.
The Orlando Police Department’s Cold Case Homicide Unit and the Florida Office of Statewide Prosecution’s Cold Case Investigation Unit worked on the investigation. The Orange County Sheriff’s Office and Daytona Beach Police Department also assisted. Officials credited Cold Case Detective Michael Fields of Orlando police and Detective David Nutting of the statewide prosecution office with helping advance the case.
Smith said detectives continued to examine the case despite the passage of nearly 13 years. Uthmeier also credited newer investigative tools and the ability to analyze older records more effectively. The announcement came after years of efforts by Johnson’s family and advocates to keep attention on the unresolved killing. Project: Cold Case, a nonprofit that works to bring attention to unsolved homicides, had featured Johnson’s case and worked with his family.
Special Counsel Richard Mantei of the Office of Statewide Prosecution is handling the prosecution in Florida’s Ninth Judicial Circuit. Officials said prosecutors expect to present the case to a grand jury. No trial dates had been announced, and authorities had not publicly detailed the defendants’ pleas or attorney representation at the time of the arrest announcement.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.