Federal Charges Target Alleged Penn State Fraternity Cocaine Supplier

Agostino Abbatiello faces seven federal drug counts over an alleged trafficking operation prosecutors say supplied two fraternity groups.

WILLIAMSPORT, PA — A former Penn State student accused of playing a leading role in a cocaine trafficking operation involving fraternity members has been indicted on seven federal drug charges, adding a federal prosecution to state charges already pending against him.

Agostino Abbatiello, 24, of Westbury, New York, was charged by a federal grand jury with one count of conspiracy to distribute cocaine and six counts of cocaine distribution, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Pennsylvania announced Nov. 18. Federal prosecutors allege Abbatiello was a major supplier of cocaine to fraternity members at Penn State University from January 2023 through December 2024. The indictment is an allegation, and Abbatiello is presumed innocent unless proved guilty.

Prosecutors allege Abbatiello repeatedly sold bulk quantities of cocaine to people associated with the Sigma Chi and Delta Upsilon fraternities, with some transactions involving as much as a kilogram. Authorities say he obtained cocaine from suppliers in Philadelphia and New York and recruited others to help obtain the drugs and transport them to State College. Prosecutors also allege fraternity brothers and pledges helped prepare and package cocaine for resale after it arrived in the area.

Abbatiello pleaded not guilty to the federal charges at an arraignment Nov. 18, according to court records reported by ABC News. A federal judge ordered him detained pending a detention hearing scheduled for Nov. 24. Federal authorities have said the charges carry a maximum possible penalty of life imprisonment, along with supervised release and a fine. Any sentence would be determined by a judge after a conviction and consideration of federal law and sentencing guidelines.

“College should be a marketplace of ideas and not illegal drugs,” U.S. Attorney Brian D. Miller said when announcing the indictment. Miller said federal prosecutors would continue working with the Pennsylvania Attorney General’s Office and law enforcement agencies investigating illegal drug activity. Homeland Security Investigations, State College police and the Pennsylvania Attorney General’s Bureau of Narcotics Investigation participated in the federal investigation.

The federal case follows a broader state investigation announced in August. Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday and State College police charged 14 people in connection with an alleged cocaine trafficking organization involving Penn State students and fraternity members. Thirteen defendants were Penn State students at or around the time of the alleged conduct in 2023 and 2024, state authorities said. At least four were current students when the charges were announced.

State investigators identified Abbatiello and Thomas Robinson as the alleged main suppliers in that case. Authorities said cocaine was obtained in large quantities from Philadelphia and New York, then prepared and packaged primarily at houses associated with Delta Upsilon and Sigma Chi before being distributed mainly to Penn State students. The attorney general’s office has alleged that some fraternity pledges took part in packaging cocaine. Those allegations have not been proved in court.

Abbatiello also faces multiple state felony charges, including allegations of conspiracy and possession with intent to deliver cocaine. At a preliminary hearing in September, a Centre County judge ordered the state charges against him to proceed to county court. Other defendants charged with felonies in the state investigation also had charges bound over for further proceedings. State officials have repeatedly stressed that the charges are allegations and that each defendant is presumed innocent unless convicted.

The criminal investigations have also led to university action involving the fraternity groups. Penn State announced Nov. 18 that Delta Upsilon had lost eligibility for university recognition for at least four years after a separate university investigation found evidence of serious misconduct and hazing. The university said that investigation also corroborated allegations involving drug misuse and distribution. Delta Upsilon had been placed on interim suspension in August after the state drug charges were announced.

Penn State said Sigma Chi operates as an unrecognized group without university oversight. The group had previously lost university recognition and has continued operating independently off campus. The university can pursue conduct cases against individual students connected to an unrecognized organization but does not have the same authority to sanction the organization itself.

The federal prosecution against Abbatiello is now moving alongside the pending Pennsylvania case. His next scheduled federal proceeding is the Nov. 24 detention hearing. No federal charges against the other people accused in the broader state investigation were announced with Abbatiello’s indictment, and prosecutors have not said whether additional federal defendants will be charged.

Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.