One man is awaiting extradition from New York while authorities continue searching for a second suspect in New York or New Jersey.
FAIRFIELD, OH — Fairfield police have identified two suspects in the fatal robbery of jewelry store owner Tara Sinchuri, saying one man was arrested in New York City and a second remains at large nearly a month after the killing.
Police said Carlos Idrogo-Arias was arrested Nov. 4 by Fairfield investigators with assistance from the U.S. Marshals Service. He remained in custody in New York pending extradition to Ohio when police announced the arrest Nov. 13. Investigators also identified Richard Guzman-Guzman as a second suspect and said they believe he is in the New York or New Jersey area. Police said Guzman-Guzman should be considered armed and dangerous.
The case began shortly before 1 p.m. Oct. 20 at Everest Jewels on Dixie Highway in Fairfield. Police said two men entered the store and spoke with Sinchuri as though they intended to make a purchase. The men then produced firearms, and a struggle followed. Sinchuri, 52, was killed, and the suspects stole valuables before leaving the store, according to police.
Investigators said an automated license plate reader system provided an early lead in the case. Fairfield police used the department’s Flock camera network to identify a possible suspect vehicle. Police said information from the cameras, combined with surveillance video from the jewelry store, helped investigators identify two suspects and obtain arrest warrants.
The investigation eventually led Fairfield detectives to New York City. Police said the U.S. Marshals Service assisted with the arrest of Idrogo-Arias. The FBI, Homeland Security Investigations and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives also provided assistance during the investigation. Fairfield police said the case required significant coordination among local and federal agencies.
Butler County Prosecutor Mike Gmoser credited the license plate reader system with helping investigators trace the vehicle connected to the robbery toward the New York area. Gmoser told local news organizations that the technology was central to identifying the suspects. He also alleged that the men are Venezuelan nationals who were in the United States illegally and were associated with a criminal group targeting jewelry businesses. Those claims were attributed to the prosecutor and had not been established through a criminal conviction.
Gmoser told WLWT that Guzman-Guzman is alleged to have been the gunman. He also said Idrogo-Arias faces aggravated murder and aggravated robbery charges and that Guzman-Guzman would face the same charges after his arrest. Other reports citing the police announcement did not specify the charges against Idrogo-Arias. Court records confirming the full charging information were not available in the material reviewed.
Sinchuri’s death brought grief to his family and members of the area’s Bhutanese-Nepali community. Relatives described him in local interviews as a family man and an active member of the community. A nephew told reporters after the killing that Sinchuri had been a positive presence who helped others and was respected by people around him. The shooting occurred as members of the family and community were observing a major Nepali religious festival.
A worker at a neighboring business told local reporters that he heard gunfire and told employees to get down. Police initially treated the case as a robbery-homicide and gathered video from surrounding businesses as investigators searched for the people responsible. Authorities released few details about possible suspects during the first weeks of the investigation before announcing the New York arrest and identifying Guzman-Guzman.
Idrogo-Arias remained subject to the extradition process to Ohio as of the latest police announcement. Guzman-Guzman had not been arrested, and investigators continued searching for him in the New York-New Jersey area. Fairfield police said the investigation remains active and asked anyone with information about either suspect to contact law enforcement.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 15, 2026.