Pavatt, 73, was put to death by lethal injection after losing a final Supreme Court bid and being denied clemency.
MCALESTER, OK — Oklahoma executed James Dwight Pavatt on Nov. 12 for the 2001 murder of Oklahoma City advertising executive Rob Andrew, bringing to a close a death penalty case that stretched nearly 25 years. Pavatt, 73, was pronounced dead at 10:12 a.m. at the Oklahoma State Penitentiary after receiving a lethal injection.
Pavatt was convicted of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit first-degree murder in Andrew’s Nov. 20, 2001, killing. Andrew, 39, was a father of two who was killed in the garage of his Oklahoma City home after arriving to pick up his children for a Thanksgiving holiday visit. Prosecutors said Pavatt and Andrew’s estranged wife, Brenda Andrew, conspired to kill him as Pavatt and Brenda Andrew were having an affair and seeking control of an $800,000 life insurance policy.
The Oklahoma Department of Corrections said the execution was completed without complications. No members of Pavatt’s family or Rob Andrew’s family attended, according to a department spokesperson. Pavatt made no final statement when asked whether he had any last words, instead shaking his head. Oklahoma Department of Corrections Executive Director Justin Farris said afterward that prison officials had carried out the court’s order while seeking to maintain dignity throughout the process.
The case began on the evening of Nov. 20, 2001, when Rob Andrew went to the family home to pick up his children. Court records say neighbors later heard gunshots, and Brenda Andrew called 911 to report that her husband had been shot. Emergency responders found Andrew in the garage and were unable to save him. Brenda Andrew had also suffered a gunshot wound to her arm. The couple’s children were elsewhere inside the home during the shooting.
Evidence presented at Pavatt’s trial showed that he knew the Andrews through church and later began a relationship with Brenda Andrew. Pavatt, who worked as an insurance agent, had also helped Rob Andrew obtain a life insurance policy worth about $800,000. Prosecutors presented evidence that Pavatt and Brenda Andrew tried to change ownership of the policy without Rob Andrew’s knowledge and argued that the insurance money was part of the motive for the killing.
The prosecution also presented evidence of an earlier attempt to harm Andrew. According to the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals, Andrew discovered in October 2001 that brake lines on his vehicle had been cut. Pavatt’s adult daughter testified that Pavatt persuaded her to make a telephone call falsely telling Andrew that Brenda Andrew was at a hospital and urgently needed him. Andrew discovered the problem with his vehicle before driving it and later reported the incident to police.
After the murder, Pavatt and Brenda Andrew left Oklahoma with the Andrews’ two children and traveled to Mexico. They were apprehended after attempting to return to the United States in February 2002. Pavatt and Brenda Andrew were prosecuted separately. A jury convicted Pavatt in 2003 of first-degree murder and conspiracy and recommended the death penalty for the murder conviction. The trial court formally imposed the sentence that October.
Pavatt spent years challenging his conviction and death sentence in state and federal courts. A federal appeals court initially granted him relief on part of his death sentence, but the full 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals later reconsidered the case and upheld both the conviction and death sentence. Pavatt continued to deny that he killed Rob Andrew. At his October clemency hearing, he told the Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board that he had been manipulated by Brenda Andrew and asked the board to spare his life.
The board voted 3-2 on Oct. 14 to deny clemency. Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond had urged the board to reject Pavatt’s request, pointing to the trial evidence and arguing that Pavatt and Brenda Andrew had planned the killing. After the execution, Drummond said justice had been served for Andrew and expressed hope that Andrew’s family could find some measure of peace after decades of grief.
Pavatt pursued a final appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court as the execution approached. On Nov. 12, the court denied his application for a stay of execution and declined to hear his petition, allowing Oklahoma to proceed. State corrections records list Pavatt’s execution date as Nov. 12, 2026.
Brenda Andrew was also convicted separately of Rob Andrew’s murder and sentenced to death. She remains listed among Oklahoma inmates sentenced to death. Pavatt’s execution came eight days before the 25th anniversary of Rob Andrew’s killing.
Author note: Last updated November 15, 2026.