KEY LARGO, FL – A shocking discovery at a luxury resort in Key Largo has left the local community reeling. Authorities have identified the body of a woman found at the Amore Dive Resort on Monday, leading to the swift arrest of a suspect.
The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office reported that deputies discovered the lifeless body of 43-year-old Nadine Marie Tillman in a room at the resort. By Tuesday, Dylan Lamb, a 33-year-old Key Largo resident, was in custody, facing charges of murder.
Tillman had reportedly met Lamb at the resort on Saturday morning. Concerns arose when Tillman’s daughter, unable to reach her mother, reported her missing. This prompted a search that led to the resort, where Tillman’s vehicle was found, and ultimately, the tragic discovery of her body.
Investigators revealed that Tillman had been beaten. A red SUV was seen at the scene and was later cordoned off with crime scene tape, though its connection to the crime remains unclear. Witnesses described seeing a man frequenting the area around the time of the incident.
Lamb, who has a history of legal troubles, including grand theft and battery, now faces a murder charge. The news has unsettled the usually peaceful resort community, where residents and visitors alike are struggling to process the event.
Despite the shock, those familiar with the resort assert its reputation as a safe and welcoming place. The incident has served as a somber reminder that violence can occur anywhere, even in the most idyllic settings.
The investigation is ongoing, with law enforcement officials urging the public to provide any information that could be helpful. As the community mourns, authorities are determined to uncover the truth behind Tillman’s tragic death.