Prosecutors allege Benjamin Carpenter planned and caused Erica Carpenter’s death after initially telling police she was injured in a fall.
WEST ALLIS, WI — A 45-year-old West Allis man was arrested Tuesday and charged with first-degree intentional homicide in the 2024 death of his wife, more than two years after police found her critically injured at the bottom of their basement stairs.
Benjamin A. Carpenter is accused of planning and causing the death of Erica A. Carpenter, according to a criminal complaint filed Nov. 17 by the Milwaukee County District Attorney’s Office. West Allis police said investigators developed probable cause during an investigation that began the night Erica was found injured. Carpenter was taken into custody Tuesday morning. The charge is an allegation, and the case has not been decided in court.
Police were sent to a home in the 2900 block of South 95th Street at about 10:38 p.m. Oct. 13, 2024, for a welfare check. Officers found Erica Carpenter at the bottom of the basement stairs with a head injury while her husband was performing CPR. Officers continued CPR until West Allis Fire Department personnel arrived. Erica was taken to a hospital and was pronounced dead at about 5:14 a.m. Oct. 14.
Benjamin Carpenter told investigators that his wife had collapsed while the couple were doing laundry in the basement, according to the criminal complaint. He said she struck her head and that he later tried to carry her upstairs. Carpenter told police he slipped while carrying her, causing both of them to fall back down the stairs and Erica to strike her head near the bottom. Prosecutors now allege the injuries and other evidence gathered during the investigation do not support his account of an accidental death.
The Milwaukee County Medical Examiner’s Office ultimately listed Erica Carpenter’s cause of death as undetermined, according to reporting based on the complaint. An autopsy found injuries to her head and neck and evidence of a brain injury associated with a lack of oxygen. Prosecutors also cited toxicology findings showing hydrocodone and medication used for insomnia in her system. Investigators have alleged that findings involving her neck could be consistent with asphyxia, though the medical examiner did not classify the death as a homicide.
The complaint also describes digital evidence that prosecutors say contributed to the homicide charge. Investigators found messages from Erica Carpenter in the weeks before her death in which she questioned her husband about what she believed was a powdery substance in her water. The complaint also says investigators reviewed Benjamin Carpenter’s internet search history and found a search during the weekend of her death asking whether pills could be crushed and taken in water. Prosecutors are using those details as part of their allegation that the death was planned rather than accidental.
Investigators also examined Carpenter’s relationship with another woman before his wife’s death. According to the complaint, the woman told authorities she did not want to continue a relationship with him while he remained married. Prosecutors allege Carpenter had discussed separating from his wife before Erica died. Those allegations form part of the prosecution’s account of events but have not been proven at trial.
Financial records also became part of the investigation. Prosecutors allege Carpenter received more than $200,000 from a life insurance policy after his wife’s death and also collected employment-related benefits. Authorities reviewed those payments along with Carpenter’s communications, phone records and other evidence during the lengthy investigation. A fundraising campaign promoted after Erica’s death also raised more than $28,000, according to local news reports.
West Allis police said the investigation remained active after Erica Carpenter’s death and eventually led investigators to conclude there was probable cause to believe Benjamin Carpenter had planned and caused it. The Milwaukee County District Attorney’s Office then filed the first-degree intentional homicide charge. An attorney representing Carpenter did not immediately respond to a Milwaukee Journal Sentinel request for comment after the charge was filed.
Carpenter remained in custody following his Nov. 17 arrest as the criminal case moved into Milwaukee County court. Police have asked anyone with additional information about Erica Carpenter’s death to contact the West Allis Police Department. No determination of Carpenter’s guilt has been made.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 18, 2026.