JUPITER, FL – In a twist of fate beneath the waves, John Moore Jr. and his friend, Matt Mansell, found themselves at the center of a legal storm. In August, while leading a shark diving tour off the coast of Jupiter, they stumbled upon something unexpected. Mansell noticed an unusual line in the water, prompting a conversation with Moore about its origin. It appeared to be a long fishing line, possibly connected to a larger operation.
Curiosity led them to investigate further. As they pulled in the line, they discovered it was attached to a hook and a shark, then another hook and another protected shark. Concerned for the marine life, they decided to bring the line to shore. Mansell and Moore alerted law enforcement, but no one seemed to have answers. Acting on instinct, they removed the line, believing they were doing the right thing.
To their dismay, the line was part of a federal research project. The realization hit hard, especially for Moore, who had never intended to break the law. Both men were charged with illegally interfering with commercial fishing gear. Convictions followed, along with fines, despite their intentions being purely altruistic.
Mansell’s attorney highlighted the jury’s struggle with the case, noting the government had to prove the men knowingly interfered with federal property. The jury deliberated for three days, torn over the decision.
Their legal battle continued with an appeal to the 11th Circuit, which was ultimately unsuccessful. However, the case drew criticism from Judge Fitzgerald, who condemned the prosecution’s decision to pursue the matter so aggressively. The judge’s remarks resonated beyond the courtroom, catching the attention of the Cato Institute, a Washington, D.C., think tank.
In a surprising turn, Mike Fox, a juror, brought the case before the House in May, revealing that the jury had sent seven notes during deliberations, seeking a way to acquit the men. Public sentiment leaned toward leniency, and eventually, a presidential pardon was granted.
A White House spokesperson noted that President Trump was committed to preventing legal overreach against citizens. The pardon not only absolved Moore and Mansell of their convictions but also restored their reputations, allowing them to reclaim their lives.