California Man Gets 32 Years, Defends Fatal Shooting

Damien Murphy told a Fresno courtroom he would not apologize after pleading no contest to voluntary manslaughter in William Carney’s death.

FRESNO, CA — A California man sentenced to 32 years in state prison for the 2023 shooting death of a father of five refused to apologize during his sentencing hearing, telling the court he believed he had acted to protect his family.

Damien Murphy was sentenced Thursday in Fresno after pleading no contest in September to voluntary manslaughter in the death of 39-year-old William Carney. The plea resolved a case that began after Carney was shot in central Fresno on Oct. 16, 2023. Murphy was denied probation and is expected to return to court in December for a restitution hearing.

When the judge gave Murphy an opportunity to address the court and Carney’s family, Murphy said, “I would apologize, but I’m not going to apologize for protecting my family. I’d do it a million times.” The judge urged Murphy to reconsider his lack of remorse and to reflect on the harm caused to Carney’s family during his prison sentence.

The fatal confrontation followed an earlier encounter involving Carney and members of Murphy’s family, according to Fresno police accounts reported after Murphy’s arrest. Authorities did not publicly explain the details of that earlier encounter or how it led to the shooting. Police said the shooting happened about 10:30 p.m. near a gas station at Belmont Avenue and Abby Street.

Investigators said gunfire-detection technology alerted officers to three rounds fired in the area. Police found Carney suffering from at least one gunshot wound. Investigators believed he had been shot south of the gas station before making his way back toward the business and collapsing. Carney was taken to Community Regional Medical Center and underwent surgery but died from his injuries.

Murphy, who was 29 when police announced his arrest in November 2023, was taken into custody after officers served search warrants at a Fresno home. He initially faced the criminal case as the person accused of killing Carney. His September 2026 no-contest plea to voluntary manslaughter avoided a first-degree murder conviction and led to the sentence imposed this month.

More than a dozen of Carney’s relatives and friends attended the sentencing, and several addressed the court about the effect of his death. Carney was the father of five children and was less than a month from his 40th birthday when he was killed. His daughter, Essence, described the loss of future milestones she expected to share with her father, while Carney’s mother spoke about the lasting grief his death caused.

The sentencing came more than three years after the shooting. During more than 20 minutes of statements from Carney’s loved ones, Murphy showed little visible reaction, according to local television coverage. One of Carney’s childhood friends told the court he did not hate Murphy, while the judge told Murphy to spend his prison term thinking about Carney, his family and the damage caused by the killing.

Murphy’s statement at sentencing drew renewed attention to a case that had remained unresolved for Carney’s family since October 2023. While the prison sentence resolves the main criminal case following Murphy’s plea, the court process is not completely finished. Murphy is scheduled to return in December for a hearing dealing with restitution.

Author note: Last updated November 15, 2026.